Rosenthal, Maurycy performance comparisons


Mazurka, Op. 63, No. 3


full tempo curve
 Rosenthal 1930

60.4%  Rosenthal 1931c
14.3%  Rosenthal 1931b
  8.4%  Rosenthal 1931
  5.9%  Rosenthal 1931d
  3.0%  Malcuzynski 1961
0.92Rosenthal 1931b
0.92Rosenthal 1931c
0.91Rosenthal 1931d
0.88Rosenthal 1931
0.70Rachmaninoff 1923
0.63Moravec 1969
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1930

62.1%  Rosenthal 1931c
  7.4%  Rosenthal 1931
  4.7%  Rachmaninoff 1923
  4.5%  Rosenthal 1931d
  3.2%  Malcuzynski 1961
  2.6%  Rosenthal 1931b
  1.7%  Moravec 1969
  1.1%  Rabcewiczowa 1932
  1.1%  Gornostaeva 1994
  1.1%  Smith 1975
0.86Rosenthal 1931c
0.84Rosenthal 1931b
0.83Rosenthal 1931d
0.82Rosenthal 1931
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1930

42.9%  Rosenthal 1931b
20.3%  Rosenthal 1931c
14.8%  Rosenthal 1931d
  5.9%  Rosenthal 1931
  1.7%  Schilhawsky 1960
  1.5%  Brailowsky 1960
  1.5%  Czerny 1949
0.88Rosenthal 1931b
0.88Rosenthal 1931d
0.86Rosenthal 1931c
0.85Rosenthal 1931
0.75Rachmaninoff 1923
0.74Brailowsky 1960
0.57Blumental 1952
0.55Horowitz 1949
global beat dynamics
 Rosenthal 1930

62.7%  Rosenthal 1931c
  6.4%  Groot 1988
  3.8%  Rachmaninoff 1923
  3.5%  Rosenthal 1931d
  2.5%  Gornostaeva 1994
  1.9%  Badura 1965
  1.7%  Rosenthal 1931b
  1.5%  Afanassiev 2001
  1.4%  Ezaki 2006
  1.3%  Uninsky 1971
  1.0%  Sztompka 1959
0.84Rosenthal 1931c
0.77Rosenthal 1931b
0.77Rosenthal 1931
0.73Rosenthal 1931d
0.58Rachmaninoff 1923
smoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1930

51.2%  Rosenthal 1931c
13.8%  Groot 1988
  4.8%  Friedman 1930
  4.0%  Rosenthal 1931
  2.5%  Harasiewicz 1955
  2.5%  Gornostaeva 1994
  1.9%  Rachmaninoff 1923
  1.9%  Czerny 1949
  1.3%  Magaloff 1978
0.73Rosenthal 1931c
0.62Rosenthal 1931
0.56Rosenthal 1931b
desmoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1930

28.8%  Rosenthal 1931d
14.6%  Afanassiev 2001
  9.4%  Rosenthal 1931b
  7.8%  Rubinstein 1939
  7.1%  Sztompka 1959
  6.1%  Ezaki 2006
  6.1%  Rachmaninoff 1923
  5.1%  Average
  2.9%  Farrell 1958
  2.1%  Gierzod 1998
  1.6%  Rosenthal 1931
0.83Rosenthal 1931b
0.82Rosenthal 1931
0.82Rosenthal 1931c
0.81Rosenthal 1931d
0.78Rachmaninoff 1923
0.75Rabcewiczowa 1932
0.68Afanassiev 2001
0.66Ezaki 2006
0.62Gornostaeva 1994
0.57Rosen 1989S
0.56Czerny 1949
0.55Sztompka 1959
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Rosenthal 1930

73.2%  Rosenthal 1931c
  8.1%  Rosenthal 1931d
  4.8%  Rosenthal 1931b
  2.8%  Rachmaninoff 1923
  2.0%  Rosenthal 1931
  1.2%  Fou 1978
  1.0%  Moravec 1969
0.93Rosenthal 1931c
0.92Rosenthal 1931b
0.91Rosenthal 1931d
0.90Rosenthal 1931
0.68Rachmaninoff 1923
full tempo curve
 Rosenthal 1931

87.6%  Rosenthal 1931b
  6.5%  Rosenthal 1931d
  2.1%  Rosenthal 1931c
0.96Rosenthal 1931d
0.96Rosenthal 1931b
0.94Rosenthal 1931c
0.88Rosenthal 1930
0.63Moravec 1969
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931

90.9%  Rosenthal 1931b
  4.5%  Rosenthal 1931d
  1.2%  Rosenthal 1931c
0.98Rosenthal 1931b
0.97Rosenthal 1931d
0.94Rosenthal 1931c
0.82Rosenthal 1930
0.57Moravec 1969
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931

79.0%  Rosenthal 1931b
  7.7%  Rosenthal 1931c
  6.5%  Rosenthal 1931d
0.94Rosenthal 1931b
0.94Rosenthal 1931d
0.90Rosenthal 1931c
0.85Rosenthal 1930
0.62Brailowsky 1960
global beat dynamics
 Rosenthal 1931

98.7%  Rosenthal 1931b
0.99Rosenthal 1931b
0.97Rosenthal 1931d
0.93Rosenthal 1931c
0.77Rosenthal 1930
smoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931

95.5%  Rosenthal 1931b
  1.4%  Rosenthal 1931d
0.97Rosenthal 1931b
0.92Rosenthal 1931d
0.78Rosenthal 1931c
0.62Rosenthal 1930
desmoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931

97.7%  Rosenthal 1931b
  1.3%  Rosenthal 1931c
1.00Rosenthal 1931b
0.97Rosenthal 1931d
0.95Rosenthal 1931c
0.84Gierzod 1998
0.82Rosenthal 1930
0.82Ferenczy 1958
0.72Ezaki 2006
0.70Afanassiev 2001
0.64Cohen 1997
0.63Anderszewski 2003
0.62Bacha 2000
0.61Badura 1965
0.59Cortot 1951
0.58Czerny 1949
0.57Brailowsky 1960
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Rosenthal 1931

97.0%  Rosenthal 1931b
  1.7%  Rosenthal 1931d
0.99Rosenthal 1931b
0.98Rosenthal 1931d
0.96Rosenthal 1931c
0.90Rosenthal 1930
0.58Brailowsky 1960
full tempo curve
 Rosenthal 1931b

67.7%  Rosenthal 1931
19.6%  Rosenthal 1931d
  9.3%  Rosenthal 1931c
  1.1%  Rosenthal 1930
0.97Rosenthal 1931d
0.96Rosenthal 1931
0.95Rosenthal 1931c
0.92Rosenthal 1930
0.62Moravec 1969
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931b

70.3%  Rosenthal 1931
24.8%  Rosenthal 1931d
  2.9%  Rosenthal 1931c
0.98Rosenthal 1931
0.98Rosenthal 1931d
0.95Rosenthal 1931c
0.84Rosenthal 1930
0.57Moravec 1969
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931b

49.7%  Rosenthal 1931
29.0%  Rosenthal 1931d
15.9%  Rosenthal 1931c
  1.8%  Rosenthal 1930
0.95Rosenthal 1931d
0.94Rosenthal 1931
0.94Rosenthal 1931c
0.88Rosenthal 1930
global beat dynamics
 Rosenthal 1931b

90.5%  Rosenthal 1931
  8.3%  Rosenthal 1931d
0.99Rosenthal 1931
0.99Rosenthal 1931d
0.93Rosenthal 1931c
0.77Rosenthal 1930
0.55Brailowsky 1960
smoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931b

54.8%  Rosenthal 1931
42.9%  Rosenthal 1931d
0.97Rosenthal 1931
0.96Rosenthal 1931d
0.79Rosenthal 1931c
0.56Rosenthal 1930
desmoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931b

91.0%  Rosenthal 1931
  7.9%  Rosenthal 1931d
1.00Rosenthal 1931
0.99Rosenthal 1931d
0.95Rosenthal 1931c
0.83Rosenthal 1930
0.82Ferenczy 1958
0.82Gierzod 1998
0.74Ezaki 2006
0.72Afanassiev 2001
0.65Brailowsky 1960
0.64Cohen 1997
0.62Anderszewski 2003
0.58Rabcewiczowa 1932
0.56Badura 1965
0.56Uninsky 1971
0.56Czerny 1949
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Rosenthal 1931b

83.0%  Rosenthal 1931
15.5%  Rosenthal 1931d
0.99Rosenthal 1931
0.99Rosenthal 1931d
0.97Rosenthal 1931c
0.92Rosenthal 1930
0.59Brailowsky 1960
full tempo curve
 Rosenthal 1931c

53.5%  Rosenthal 1931b
30.4%  Rosenthal 1931d
  8.6%  Rosenthal 1931
  3.8%  Rosenthal 1930
0.96Rosenthal 1931d
0.95Rosenthal 1931b
0.94Rosenthal 1931
0.92Rosenthal 1930
0.65Moravec 1969
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931c

47.4%  Rosenthal 1931b
24.0%  Rosenthal 1931
21.5%  Rosenthal 1931d
  2.0%  Rosenthal 1930
0.95Rosenthal 1931b
0.94Rosenthal 1931d
0.94Rosenthal 1931
0.86Rosenthal 1930
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931c

48.3%  Rosenthal 1931b
34.9%  Rosenthal 1931d
  6.5%  Rosenthal 1931
  4.4%  Rosenthal 1930
0.94Rosenthal 1931d
0.94Rosenthal 1931b
0.90Rosenthal 1931
0.86Rosenthal 1930
0.58Rachmaninoff 1923
0.55Brailowsky 1960
0.55Moravec 1969
global beat dynamics
 Rosenthal 1931c

47.4%  Rosenthal 1931b
22.4%  Rosenthal 1931
13.5%  Rosenthal 1930
  7.0%  Rosenthal 1931d
  1.5%  Paderewski 1930
0.93Rosenthal 1931
0.93Rosenthal 1931b
0.92Rosenthal 1931d
0.84Rosenthal 1930
smoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931c

43.0%  Rosenthal 1930
14.1%  Rosenthal 1931
10.8%  Rosenthal 1931b
  6.0%  Smith 1975
  4.9%  Paderewski 1930
  3.7%  Magaloff 1978
  3.5%  Rosenthal 1931d
  2.3%  Gierzod 1998
0.79Rosenthal 1931b
0.78Rosenthal 1931
0.77Rosenthal 1931d
0.73Rosenthal 1930
desmoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931c

67.9%  Rosenthal 1931b
14.6%  Rosenthal 1931
  8.3%  Rosenthal 1931d
  2.6%  Cohen 1997
0.95Rosenthal 1931
0.95Rosenthal 1931b
0.94Rosenthal 1931d
0.82Rosenthal 1930
0.71Ezaki 2006
0.70Cortot 1951
0.69Cohen 1997
0.65Gierzod 1998
0.59Ferenczy 1958
0.58Czerny 1949
0.56Mohovich 1999
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Rosenthal 1931c

62.8%  Rosenthal 1931b
14.3%  Rosenthal 1931d
11.4%  Rosenthal 1931
  8.2%  Rosenthal 1930
0.97Rosenthal 1931b
0.96Rosenthal 1931
0.96Rosenthal 1931d
0.93Rosenthal 1930
0.58Magaloff 1978
full tempo curve
 Rosenthal 1931d

73.3%  Rosenthal 1931b
14.0%  Rosenthal 1931c
  9.7%  Rosenthal 1931
  1.5%  Rosenthal 1930
0.97Rosenthal 1931b
0.96Rosenthal 1931
0.96Rosenthal 1931c
0.91Rosenthal 1930
0.62Moravec 1969
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931d

85.1%  Rosenthal 1931b
  7.6%  Rosenthal 1931
  5.0%  Rosenthal 1931c
0.98Rosenthal 1931b
0.97Rosenthal 1931
0.94Rosenthal 1931c
0.83Rosenthal 1930
0.57Moravec 1969
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931d

66.8%  Rosenthal 1931b
21.1%  Rosenthal 1931c
  6.8%  Rosenthal 1931
  2.9%  Rosenthal 1930
0.95Rosenthal 1931b
0.94Rosenthal 1931c
0.94Rosenthal 1931
0.88Rosenthal 1930
0.62Brailowsky 1960
0.57Rachmaninoff 1923
global beat dynamics
 Rosenthal 1931d

97.0%  Rosenthal 1931b
0.99Rosenthal 1931b
0.97Rosenthal 1931
0.92Rosenthal 1931c
0.73Rosenthal 1930
smoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931d

90.6%  Rosenthal 1931b
  4.2%  Rosenthal 1931
0.96Rosenthal 1931b
0.92Rosenthal 1931
0.77Rosenthal 1931c
0.55Magaloff 1978
desmoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Rosenthal 1931d

94.3%  Rosenthal 1931b
  2.2%  Rosenthal 1931
  1.3%  Gornostaeva 1994
0.99Rosenthal 1931b
0.97Rosenthal 1931
0.94Rosenthal 1931c
0.81Rosenthal 1930
0.71Rabcewiczowa 1932
0.68Ezaki 2006
0.65Ferenczy 1958
0.62Afanassiev 2001
0.57Cohen 1997
0.55Czerny 1949
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Rosenthal 1931d

94.1%  Rosenthal 1931b
  3.1%  Rosenthal 1931
  1.7%  Rosenthal 1931c
0.99Rosenthal 1931b
0.98Rosenthal 1931
0.96Rosenthal 1931c
0.91Rosenthal 1930
0.62Brailowsky 1960