Hatto, Joyce performance comparisons


Mazurka, Op. 17, No. 4


full tempo curve
 Hatto 1997

99.8%  Indjic 2001
1.00Indjic 2001
0.68Milkina 1970
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

99.9%  Indjic 2001
1.00Indjic 2001
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

99.8%  Indjic 2001
1.00Indjic 2001
0.75Milkina 1970
0.66Rangell 2001
0.66Ashkenazy 1981
0.63Lushtak 2004
0.61Kissin 1993
0.60Perlemuter 1986
0.58Rubinstein 1939
0.58Mohovich 1999
0.56Perahia 1994
0.55Uninsky 1971
0.55Cohen 1997
global beat dynamics
 Hatto 1997

98.7%  Indjic 2001
0.99Indjic 2001
0.56Levy 1951
0.56Falvay 1989
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1997

99.7%  Indjic 2001
1.00Indjic 2001
0.62Milkina 1970
0.59Ashkenazy 1981

Mazurka, Op. 24, No. 2


full tempo curve
 Hatto 1993

57.9%  Indjic 2001
41.2%  Hatto 1997
0.99Hatto 1997
0.99Indjic 2001
0.86Average
0.71Osinska 1989
0.70Nezu 2005
0.68Lushtak 2004
0.67Malcuzynski 1961
0.67Tsujii 2005
0.67Malcuzynski 1951
0.65Poblocka 1999
0.65Falvay 1989
0.62Rangell 2001
0.62Ohlsson 1999
0.60Milkina 1970
0.60Olejniczak 1990
0.59Shebanova 2002
0.57Uninsky 1959
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1993

63.9%  Indjic 2001
35.6%  Hatto 1997
1.00Hatto 1997
1.00Indjic 2001
0.74Average
0.63Magin 1975
0.63Rangell 2001
0.61Poblocka 1999
0.57Osinska 1989
0.57Malcuzynski 1961
0.57Malcuzynski 1951
0.56Biret 1990
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1993

55.4%  Indjic 2001
43.5%  Hatto 1997
0.99Hatto 1997
0.99Indjic 2001
0.77Average
0.69Nezu 2005
0.68Tsujii 2005
0.68Lushtak 2004
0.67Ohlsson 1999
0.67Osinska 1989
0.66Luisada 2008
0.66Malcuzynski 1951
0.65Malcuzynski 1961
0.65Fiorentino 1962
0.59Katin 1996
0.58Luisada 1990
global beat dynamics
 Hatto 1993

95.5%  Indjic 2001
  3.8%  Hatto 1997
0.99Hatto 1997
0.99Indjic 2001
0.71Average
0.64Magin 1975
0.63Falvay 1989
0.62Zimerman 1975
0.58Shebanova 2002
0.57Fliere 1977
0.56Fou 1978
0.55Luisada 1990
0.55Barbosa 1983
smoothed beat dynamics
 Hatto 1993

59.4%  Hatto 1997
39.2%  Indjic 2001
0.99Indjic 2001
0.98Hatto 1997
0.55Sztompka 1959
desmoothed beat dynamics
 Hatto 1993

95.5%  Indjic 2001
  3.6%  Hatto 1997
0.99Hatto 1997
0.99Indjic 2001
0.69Average
0.68Luisada 1990
0.68Fliere 1977
0.62Poblocka 1999
0.61Zimerman 1975
0.60Fou 1978
0.56Rubinstein 1939
0.56Ashkenazy 1981
0.55Bacha 1998
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1993

89.5%  Indjic 2001
10.2%  Hatto 1997
1.00Hatto 1997
1.00Indjic 2001
0.87Average
0.73Malcuzynski 1961
0.72Falvay 1989
0.72Poblocka 1999
0.69Magin 1975
0.66Ohlsson 1999
0.63Uninsky 1959
0.63Nezu 2005
0.62Osinska 1989
0.61Shebanova 2002
0.59Zimerman 1975
0.58Katin 1996
0.58Fou 1978
0.55Lushtak 2004
0.55Tsujii 2005
smoothed joint features
 Hatto 1993

76.5%  Indjic 2001
23.2%  Hatto 1997
1.00Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1997
0.77Average
0.75Magin 1975
0.66Falvay 1989
0.63Malcuzynski 1961
0.61Poblocka 1999
0.60Uninsky 1959
0.56Shebanova 2002
desmoothed joint features
 Hatto 1993

92.7%  Indjic 2001
  6.8%  Hatto 1997
1.00Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1997
0.86Average
0.78Luisada 1990
0.71Tsujii 2005
0.71Malcuzynski 1961
0.69Falvay 1989
0.67Lushtak 2004
0.66Fiorentino 1962
0.66Fou 1978
0.65Poblocka 1999
0.65Rubinstein 1939
0.62Vardi 1988
0.62Nezu 2005
0.61Fliere 1977
0.60Zimerman 1975
0.57Olejniczak 1990
0.57Luisada 2008
0.55BenOr 1989
full tempo curve
 Hatto 1997

90.5%  Indjic 2001
  8.9%  Hatto 1993
1.00Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1993
0.86Average
0.72Nezu 2005
0.71Osinska 1989
0.69Lushtak 2004
0.67Tsujii 2005
0.66Rangell 2001
0.66Poblocka 1999
0.64Malcuzynski 1961
0.63Falvay 1989
0.63Malcuzynski 1951
0.62Milkina 1970
0.62Ohlsson 1999
0.61Shebanova 2002
0.59Uninsky 1959
0.59Olejniczak 1990
0.58Magin 1975
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

92.0%  Indjic 2001
  7.6%  Hatto 1993
1.00Hatto 1993
1.00Indjic 2001
0.73Average
0.65Magin 1975
0.64Rangell 2001
0.60Poblocka 1999
0.59Biret 1990
0.57Malcuzynski 1951
0.57Malcuzynski 1961
0.55Osinska 1989
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

89.8%  Indjic 2001
  9.4%  Hatto 1993
0.99Hatto 1993
0.99Indjic 2001
0.77Average
0.73Lushtak 2004
0.73Nezu 2005
0.72Ohlsson 1999
0.70Tsujii 2005
0.70Osinska 1989
0.65Luisada 2008
0.63Katin 1996
0.60Fiorentino 1962
0.60Milkina 1970
0.59Vardi 1988
0.57Malcuzynski 1951
0.57Malcuzynski 1961
0.56Kushner 1990
global beat dynamics
 Hatto 1997

90.1%  Indjic 2001
  8.8%  Hatto 1993
0.99Hatto 1993
0.99Indjic 2001
0.73Average
0.66Falvay 1989
0.59Shebanova 2002
0.59Uninsky 1959
0.58Magin 1975
0.56Ohlsson 1999
0.56Fliere 1977
0.56Sztompka 1959
0.55Poblocka 1999
smoothed beat dynamics
 Hatto 1997

84.2%  Indjic 2001
13.6%  Hatto 1993
0.98Hatto 1993
0.98Indjic 2001
0.57Shebanova 2002
0.56Ohlsson 1999
0.56Falvay 1989
0.55Sztompka 1959
desmoothed beat dynamics
 Hatto 1997

91.8%  Indjic 2001
  7.1%  Hatto 1993
0.99Hatto 1993
0.99Indjic 2001
0.67Luisada 1990
0.66Fliere 1977
0.65Average
0.64Poblocka 1999
0.61Csalog 1996
0.58Ashkenazy 1981
0.58Rubinstein 1939
0.56Horszowski 1983
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1997

92.8%  Indjic 2001
  6.9%  Hatto 1993
1.00Hatto 1993
1.00Indjic 2001
0.88Average
0.74Falvay 1989
0.73Malcuzynski 1961
0.72Poblocka 1999
0.71Ohlsson 1999
0.71Magin 1975
0.69Uninsky 1959
0.66Nezu 2005
0.64Shebanova 2002
0.63Osinska 1989
0.58Katin 1996
0.58Tsujii 2005
0.57Fou 1978
0.56Zimerman 1975
smoothed joint features
 Hatto 1997

92.1%  Indjic 2001
  7.5%  Hatto 1993
1.00Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1993
0.76Magin 1975
0.75Average
0.67Falvay 1989
0.64Malcuzynski 1961
0.62Uninsky 1959
0.60Poblocka 1999
0.59Shebanova 2002
desmoothed joint features
 Hatto 1997

94.0%  Indjic 2001
  5.6%  Hatto 1993
1.00Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1993
0.85Average
0.71Tsujii 2005
0.70Nezu 2005
0.70Falvay 1989
0.69Lushtak 2004
0.68Luisada 1990
0.66Poblocka 1999
0.64Malcuzynski 1961
0.64Rubinstein 1939
0.62Fou 1978
0.62Osinska 1989
0.61Vardi 1988
0.58BenOr 1989
0.58Malcuzynski 1951
0.58Fliere 1977
0.56Luisada 2008

Mazurka, Op. 30, No. 2


full tempo curve
 Hatto 1997

98.6%  Indjic 2001
0.99Indjic 2001
0.76Average
0.64Luisada 1990
0.64Rubinstein 1952
0.60Poblocka 1999
0.59Rubinstein 1939
0.55Milkina 1970
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

99.1%  Indjic 2001
0.99Indjic 2001
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

98.1%  Indjic 2001
0.99Indjic 2001
0.87Average
0.75Rubinstein 1952
0.74Poblocka 1999
0.71Rubinstein 1939
0.69Biret 1990
0.67Luisada 1990
0.65Milkina 1970
0.64Francois 1956
0.55Fliere 1977
0.55Olejniczac 1990
0.55Rubinstein 1966
global beat dynamics
 Hatto 1997

97.8%  Indjic 2001
0.99Indjic 2001
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1997

99.3%  Indjic 2001
1.00Indjic 2001

Mazurka, Op. 63, No. 3


full tempo curve
 Hatto 1993

77.9%  Indjic 1988
21.6%  Hatto 1997
1.00Indjic 1988
0.99Hatto 1997
0.67Average
0.61Gierzod 1998
0.60Friedman 1923b
0.59Osinska 1989
0.58Friedman 1923
0.57Uninsky 1971
0.56Fliere 1977
0.56Czerny 1949
0.55Harasiewicz 1955
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1993

67.9%  Indjic 1988
31.8%  Hatto 1997
1.00Hatto 1997
1.00Indjic 1988
0.67Friedman 1923b
0.66Friedman 1923
0.61Friedman 1930
0.56Neighaus 1950
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1993

77.5%  Indjic 1988
21.8%  Hatto 1997
0.99Indjic 1988
0.99Hatto 1997
0.77Average
0.70Osinska 1989
0.70Harasiewicz 1955
0.67Czerny 1990
0.67Gierzod 1998
0.66Rubinstein 1966
0.66Blumental 1952
0.60Czerny 1949
0.60Magaloff 1978
0.59Uninsky 1971
0.56Shebanova 2002
global beat dynamics
 Hatto 1993

99.0%  Indjic 1988
0.99Indjic 1988
0.94Hatto 1997
0.74Ashkenazy 1981
0.65Luisada 1991
0.56Magin 1975
smoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Hatto 1993

98.5%  Indjic 1988
0.99Indjic 1988
0.90Hatto 1997
0.61Ashkenazy 1981
0.55Anderszewski 2003
desmoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Hatto 1993

98.5%  Indjic 1988
0.99Indjic 1988
0.94Hatto 1997
0.87Ashkenazy 1981
0.82Magin 1975
0.78Shebanova 2002
0.75Luisada 1991
0.74Richter 1976
0.73Kapell 1951
0.71Groot 1988
0.68Czerny 1990
0.67Garcia 2007b
0.67Kissin 1993
0.62Chiu 1999
0.62Barbosa 1983
0.61Paderewski 1930
0.60Average
0.59Niedzielski 1931
0.57Michalowski 1933
0.57Blumental 1952
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1993

99.4%  Indjic 1988
1.00Indjic 1988
0.99Hatto 1997
0.64Ashkenazy 1981
0.62Luisada 1991
0.56Shebanova 2002
0.55Ohlsson 1999
smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1993

99.0%  Indjic 1988
1.00Indjic 1988
0.97Hatto 1997
0.57Ashkenazy 1981
0.56Luisada 1991
0.55Anderszewski 2003
desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1993

99.0%  Indjic 1988
1.00Indjic 1988
0.98Hatto 1997
0.77Average
0.75Czerny 1990
0.75Groot 1988
0.75Blumental 1952
0.72Shebanova 2002
0.70Magin 1975
0.65Ashkenazy 1981
0.64Luisada 1991
0.64Barbosa 1983
0.63Garcia 2007b
0.60Milkina 1970
0.59Harasiewicz 1955
0.56Kapell 1951
0.55Kissin 1993
full tempo curve
 Hatto 1997

68.1%  Indjic 1988
31.8%  Hatto 1993
1.00Indjic 1988
0.99Hatto 1993
0.68Average
0.62Gierzod 1998
0.61Osinska 1989
0.60Friedman 1923b
0.59Friedman 1923
0.57Uninsky 1971
0.56Czerny 1949
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

66.9%  Indjic 1988
33.0%  Hatto 1993
1.00Hatto 1993
1.00Indjic 1988
0.67Friedman 1923b
0.66Friedman 1923
0.61Friedman 1930
0.55Neighaus 1950
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

68.3%  Indjic 1988
31.4%  Hatto 1993
1.00Indjic 1988
0.99Hatto 1993
0.78Average
0.72Osinska 1989
0.69Rubinstein 1966
0.67Czerny 1990
0.66Gierzod 1998
0.65Harasiewicz 1955
0.61Blumental 1952
0.58Magaloff 1978
0.57Czerny 1949
0.57Uninsky 1971
0.55Groot 1988
global beat dynamics
 Hatto 1997

90.2%  Indjic 1988
  2.5%  Hatto 1993
0.95Indjic 1988
0.94Hatto 1993
0.59Anderszewski 2003
0.59Ashkenazy 1981
0.56Biret 1990
0.55Luisada 1991
smoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

87.6%  Indjic 1988
  1.1%  Hatto 1993
0.92Indjic 1988
0.90Hatto 1993
0.59Anderszewski 2003
desmoothed dynamics (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

78.7%  Indjic 1988
13.8%  Hatto 1993
0.96Indjic 1988
0.94Hatto 1993
0.71Luisada 1991
0.64Rubinstein 1952
0.61Kapell 1951
0.58Milkina 1970
0.58Barbosa 1983
0.57Afanassiev 2001
0.57Biret 1990
0.56Tomsic 1995
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1997

96.5%  Indjic 1988
  2.2%  Hatto 1993
0.99Hatto 1993
0.99Indjic 1988
0.57Average
smoothed joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1997

95.0%  Indjic 1988
  2.5%  Hatto 1993
0.98Indjic 1988
0.97Hatto 1993
0.55Ashkenazy 1981
desmoothed joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1997

86.0%  Indjic 1988
12.4%  Hatto 1993
0.99Indjic 1988
0.98Hatto 1993
0.73Average
0.69Uninsky 1971
0.68Milkina 1970
0.66Rubinstein 1966
0.66Blumental 1952
0.64Biret 1990
0.63Rubinstein 1952
0.59Luisada 1991
0.58Rubinstein 1939
0.57Barbosa 1983
0.57Czerny 1990
0.56Groot 1988

Mazurka, Op. 68, No. 3


full tempo curve
 Hatto 1993

62.5%  Hatto 1997
36.8%  Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1997
0.99Indjic 2001
0.71Bacha 1997
0.65Average Tempo
0.59Kapell 1951
0.58Biret 1990
0.58Kushner 1989
0.58Niedzielski 1931
0.58Ashkenazy 1981
0.56Meguri 1997
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1993

70.4%  Indjic 2001
28.9%  Hatto 1997
0.99Hatto 1997
0.99Indjic 2001
0.67Bacha 1997
0.63Smidowicz 1948
0.63Smidowicz 1948b
0.63Grinberg 1951
0.61Biret 1990
0.59Csalog 1996
0.58Kushner 1989
0.58Kapell 1951
0.57Ashkenazy 1981
0.55Francois 1956
0.55Average Tempo
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1993

63.1%  Hatto 1997
36.2%  Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1997
0.99Indjic 2001
0.73Shebanova 2002
0.67Bacha 1997
0.61Ferenczy 1958
0.59Average Tempo
0.56Ohlsson 1999
0.56Meguri 1997
global beat dynamics
 Hatto 1993

82.0%  Indjic 2001
14.4%  Hatto 1997
0.97Indjic 2001
0.95Hatto 1997
0.68Average Tempo
0.66Mohovich 1999
0.66Bacha 1997
0.65Kapell 1951
0.64Ohlsson 1999
0.62Czerny 1990
0.61Fou 1978
0.60Ezaki 2006
0.60Kushner 1989
0.59Ferenczy 1958
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1993

79.1%  Indjic 2001
20.0%  Hatto 1997
0.99Hatto 1997
0.98Indjic 2001
0.84Kapell 1951
0.84Bacha 1997
0.81Average Tempo
0.77Kushner 1989
0.76Mohovich 1999
0.72Meguri 1997
0.69Czerny 1990
0.66Ohlsson 1999
0.66Ferenczy 1958
0.64Ezaki 2006
0.61Uninsky 1971
0.61Csalog 1996
0.58Olejniczak 1990
0.57Fliere 1977
full tempo curve
 Hatto 1997

64.9%  Hatto 1993
34.5%  Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1993
0.99Indjic 2001
0.70Bacha 1997
0.63Average Tempo
0.61Biret 1990
0.60Ashkenazy 1981
0.60Kapell 1951
0.58Kushner 1989
0.57Niedzielski 1931
0.56Meguri 1997
smoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

60.8%  Hatto 1993
38.8%  Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1993
0.99Indjic 2001
0.67Bacha 1997
0.63Grinberg 1951
0.62Smidowicz 1948
0.62Biret 1990
0.62Smidowicz 1948b
0.59Csalog 1996
0.58Kushner 1989
0.57Kapell 1951
0.56Ashkenazy 1981
0.55Francois 1956
0.55Average Tempo
desmoothed tempo curve (0.5)
 Hatto 1997

65.8%  Hatto 1993
33.5%  Indjic 2001
0.99Indjic 2001
0.99Hatto 1993
0.71Shebanova 2002
0.68Bacha 1997
0.64Meguri 1997
0.64Ferenczy 1958
0.60Ohlsson 1999
0.57Fliere 1977
global beat dynamics
 Hatto 1997

93.3%  Indjic 2001
  1.6%  Hatto 1993
0.97Indjic 2001
0.95Hatto 1993
0.75Kapell 1951
0.75Average Tempo
0.72Fou 1978
0.66Ohlsson 1999
0.65Uninsky 1971
0.64Ezaki 2006
0.64Ferenczy 1958
0.62Mohovich 1999
0.62Bacha 1997
0.60Kushner 1989
joint tempo / global dynamics
 Hatto 1997

94.7%  Indjic 2001
  4.0%  Hatto 1993
0.99Hatto 1993
0.99Indjic 2001
0.88Kapell 1951
0.86Average Tempo
0.84Bacha 1997
0.78Kushner 1989
0.72Meguri 1997
0.71Uninsky 1971
0.71Ferenczy 1958
0.70Ezaki 2006
0.69Mohovich 1999
0.67Ohlsson 1999
0.67Csalog 1996
0.65Czerny 1990
0.58Biret 1990
0.57Olejniczak 1990
0.57Tomsic 1995